[FIXED] Selenium driver.Url vs. driver.Navigate().GoToUrl()

Issue

Which is the preferred method to open a Url (and are there any differences behind the scenes between):

driver.Url = "http://example.com";

or

driver.Navigate().GoToUrl("http://example.com");

Also, if the driver is already pointing at the same page, will setting the Url a second time cause the page to refresh?

i.e.

...
driver.Url = "http://example.com";
driver.Url = "http://example.com"; //does this reload the page?
...

FWIW I'm using the Chrome driver chromedriver.exe, but it doesn't appear to be a managed assembly (I tried opening it with ILSpy but no luck).

Solution

Selenium is an open source framework, so please have a look at the source code here.

GoToUrl() is defined in RemoteNavigator.cs:

/// <summary>
/// Navigate to a url for your test
/// </summary>
/// <param name="url">String of where you want the browser to go to</param>
public void GoToUrl(string url)
{
    this.driver.Url = url;
}

/// <summary>
/// Navigate to a url for your test
/// </summary>
/// <param name="url">Uri object of where you want the browser to go to</param>
public void GoToUrl(Uri url)
{
    if (url == null)
    {
        throw new ArgumentNullException("url", "URL cannot be null.");
    }

    this.driver.Url = url.ToString();
}

So basically driver.Navigate().GoToUrl(); sets driver.Url under the hood and I don't see a difference there.

However, driver.Navigate().GoToUrl() is more flexible, which allows sending either string or Uri as parameter types, while only string is allowed when setting through driver.Url.

---

To your second question, the source code shows that driver.Navigate().Refresh() asks browsers to refresh, while driver.Url tells browsers to navigate. So these two are fundamentally different. For more details, please see Difference between Refresh and Navigate function in browser control?

If you want to refresh the page, please use driver.Navigate().Refresh();

Refresh() is defined in RemoteNavigator.cs:

/// <summary>
/// Refresh the browser
/// </summary>
public void Refresh()
{
    // driver.SwitchTo().DefaultContent();
    this.driver.InternalExecute(DriverCommand.Refresh, null);
}

driver.Url is defined in RemoteWebDriver.cs:

public string Url
{
    ...

    set
    {
        ...

        try
        {
            this.Execute(DriverCommand.Get, parameters);
        }
        ...
    }
}

Answered By - Yi Zeng